Instead, we can attribute it to the shortcomings of Matthew. And we can take a lesson from it.
Real life includes murders and tragedies – like that which happened in reality at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Connecticut recently, and like that depicted in story in Matthew's Gospel.
But when we insert God as a character and say that God acted to save some, we turn God into a monster who chooses for inscrutable reasons to spare some but lead others to the slaughter.Tony responds,
Like many liberals, he brushes off the deeper implications of the text in order to assuage his modern sensibilities...
You see, that's exactly what happens when you dismiss the terrifying texts of the Bible as non-literal myths. YOU SILENCE THE VICTIMS!
It's true that we don’t know how many infant boys Herod murdered. We don't know if it was just the sons of a couple families, a village, or a whole territory. But does it matter?!? Innocent infants were killed. They were not myths. They were not fables. They were babies!
James wants to mythologize this story because that lets God off the hook. If it's a myth, then it means that God didn't work to save Joseph's family while allowing other families to suffer infanticide. But this is what happens every day, every time a baby dies — of a genetic disorder or in a car accident or at the hands of a murderous madman — God, it seems, protects one and does not protect the other.For what it's worth I'm with Tony on this. Yes, it is difficult to comprehend why some live and others die, but to suggest that God must save all or save none not only takes us in the direction of deism, it turns God into the Great Bureaucrat in the Sky who acts more according to standard procedure than in dynamic relationship.
In Jesus Christ, God gives us his real presence and enters the midst of the muck and mire of the human situation in all of its mess and malady. In an analogical sense Incarnation is God rolling up his sleeves and getting his hands dirty in order to lift us out of the muck and the mess.
No doubt, James will respond to Tony's critique.