A Weblog Dedicated to the Discussion of the Christian Faith and 21st Century Life

A Weblog Dedicated to the Discussion of the Christian Faith and 21st Century Life

This blog is a place for the discussion of all things significant and not so important as well. If you read something you disagree with, don't get angry; post a comment and join the discussion.

Passionate and lively debate is encouraged in the context of civility. Comments that include name calling and profanity will be deleted.

Tuesday, November 30, 2010

Advent Meditation: Hope Amidst the Rubble

And you, child, will be called the prophet of the Most High; for you will go before the Lord to prepare his ways, to give knowledge of salvation to his people by the forgiveness of their sins. By the tender mercy of our God, the dawn from on high will break upon us, to give light to those who sit in darkness and in the shadow of death, to guide our feet into the way of peace (Luke 1:76-79).

It started in 1992-- the siege of Sarajevo, the capital of Bosnia and Herzegovina during the Bosnian War. Within a short period of time, the city, a historic center of art, music, and culture, was being pounded into rubble. The residents did their best to hide in their homes. People were being injured and killed. There was a serious shortage of food. The people of the city were losing hope.

On May 27, 1992 at four o'clock in the afternoon, a mortar dropped in the middle of one of the few operational bakeries in the city. Twenty-two people were killed, most of them standing in line to get bread. One resident of the city decided he had to do what little he could for the residents of his beloved Sarajevo.

His name was Vedran Smailovic and he was the principal cellist with the Sarajevo Opera. On the Sunday evening following the bakery massacre, Smailovic, with cello in hand, walked to the site where the bakery had stood and at 4:00 p.m., the time of the bombing, played a concert for the people in full tux and tails. He played for twenty-two straight days in memory of the people who had been killed at the bakery. Smailovic played despite the fact that bombs and bullets were falling and flying around him. After the twenty-two days were completed the cellist continued to play in various places-- graveyards and bombed out buildings-- he offered his peaceful and serene music in places that where peace and serenity had been shattered. Smailovic played amidst the rubble until December 1993. As one writer put it:

He played to ruined homes, smouldering fires, scared people hiding in basements. He played for human dignity that is the first casualty in war. Ultimately, he played for life, for peace, and for the possibility of hope that exists even in the darkest hour. Asked by a journalist whether he was not crazy doing what he was doing, Smailovic replied: "You ask me am I crazy for playing the cello, why do you not ask if they are not crazy for shelling Sarajevo?"*

In this Advent season, in the midst of the rubble of the world, in the midst of the pain and suffering, in the midst of communities torn asunder by the ravages of war, and in the midst of the personal pains and loss, grief, and financial ruin-- the church by its life together and in its service to the world, offers hope.

There are people around us, and... yes... in the church, who have given up hope. For those who have abandoned hope, or at the very least, have been tempted to give up hope, Luke reminds us that the birth of John the Baptist, the sign of hope, and the birth of Jesus, our actual hope, have occurred while Israel suffered under the domination of Rome and the vassal and puppet king of Rome, Herod. It is not an accident that Luke begins his Gospel by setting the advent of God's wonderful new hope "in the time of King Herod of Judea" (1:5). But God did not act through Herod or Caesar. Instead, God visited an elderly priest and his wife, who had no children, and who had given up hope of having children, and worked through unexpected people in incredible circumstance. In the midst of their oppression God visited his people giving them hope.

In this Advent season may God's people in their worship and fellowship and ministry play the Great Song of Hope that is the gospel!

___

For further reading on the cellist of Sarajevo:

*Swati Chopra, "The cellist of Sarajevo"

"Vedran Smailovic"

Steven Galloway, The Cellist of Sarajevo. Riverhead Trade, Reprint 2009.

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Tuesday 11.30.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Posts to ponder from the Methoblogosphere:

Bishop William Willimon writes on impacting church attendance.

Kim Matthews has been blogging for five years!

Mike Hudson points out that social justice begins at home.

It's family time and baby preparation for Andrew Conard.

Laurie Haller reflects on being the servant of the Lord.

Beth Quick posts her lectionary notes for the Second Sunday of Advent.

Will Rice reviews the book, Mistakes Were Made (but not by me).

There is reason to be optimistic for Jewish-Methodist relations, says David Hallam.

John Meunier is working through running the race.

Paul Jeffrey comments on Advent waiting in Southern Sudan.

Christmas future is far away... for Theresa Coleman.

Where are the Methodist class meetings for the 21st Century? Read Kevin Watson.

Monday, November 29, 2010

What Do You Mean By Literal?

Peter Enns interviews N.T. Wright



The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Monday 11.29.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Today's reads from the Methoblogosphere:

For Mark Winter, Advent begins at First UMC, Cleburne.

Robert McDowell writes on two TVs, one happy family.

John Carney reminds us that the night is far gone.

An Advent devotional from Dave Camphouse.

Sue Whitt says that it's time to wake up.

Dave Faulkner also wants to roust us from our slumber.

Jennifer Smith ponders a six-year-old's question about Christmas.

When it comes to Advent, once more with feeling, writes Dan Dick.

Henry Neufeld comments on Wesleyan-Arminian vs. Calvinist Self-Identification.

Sonja Tobey reflects on the family Advent wreath.

Matt Kelley issues a Black Friday challenge.

Reflections on past, present, and future Advent expectations from Angela Shier-Jones.

Sunday, November 28, 2010

A Prayer for the First Sunday in Advent

Merciful God, you sent your messengers the prophets to preach repentance and prepare the way for our salvation. Give us grace to heed their warnings and forsake our sins, that we may greet with joy the coming of Jesus Christ, our Redeemer; who lives and reigns with you and the Holy Spirit, one God, now and forever. Amen.

The Book of Worship (UMC)

Saturday, November 27, 2010

Small Business Saturday

Today is Small Business Saturday. Since many people participated yesterday in the nonsense called "Black Friday" in the attempt to feed their greed, I think those same persons ought to participate in Small Business Saturday today.

Some facts:

-For every $100 spent at a local small business, $68 returns to the community.-- Civic Economics

-Half of all private sector employees work for small businesses.-- Small Business Administration

-Small businesses represent 99.7% of all employer firms.-- Small Business Administration

-Every year over the last decade, 60%-80% of new jobs were generated by small business.-- Small Business Administration

So, for those who couldn't resist yesterday's greedfest, do your local business owners a favor today and eat at a local restaurant or buy something from a small shop owner in the area... after all you should have plenty of money from what you saved yesterday pushing and shoving to get one of those five techie gadgets in stock.

Madison Avenue pulled your strings yesterday. Do something of real value today and support a local business owner.

The Methodist Blogs Weekly Roundup 2010.30.241

Any Methoblogger who would like a link in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

If you discover that a link is not correct, please email me at the above address.

*Thanks to everyone for their email submissions.*

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Monday 11.22.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Tuesday 11.23.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Wednesday 11.24.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Thursday 11.25.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Friday 11.26.10

This week's Best of the Methoblogosphere!

Tony Mitchell: "Time Has Come Today"

Katie Ladd: "God's Shalom/God's Kingdom"

Friday, November 26, 2010

Black Friday-- 'Tis the Season!

I was going to write a post on Black Friday and the celebration of Christmas being the armchair cultural critic that I am. But as I started reading some of the news reports coming in on such shameful behavior today, all in the name of the celebration of the Prince of Peace, I decided that I need to say nothing. All I have to do is link the reports.

So, here they are:

Crazed Shoppers Involved in Pile Up

Mall Food Court Placed on Lockdown after Argument and Gunshots

Enraged Shopper Arrested after Cutting in Line

Police Called after Mad Rush at Toys R Us

Woman Arrested after Gun Threat in Toy Store

Man Caught with Guns, Knives, and Pepper Grenade at Walmart
.
UPDATE: A Marine Helping with Toys for Tots is Stabbed

I think that is sufficiently depressing information for now. I just love it that in this holiday season we celebrate the birth of One who freely gave up everything on our behalf so that we can teach our children that it is OK to push and shove and feed our greed because they deserve whatever they want for Christmas because it really is their birthday, and not some poor kid's who was born in Bethlehem two millennia ago. Perhaps the church should change its liturgical season from Advent to Avarice... after all we are not so much preparing our lives for the birth of Christ as we are getting ready for the Greedfest on the morning of December 25th.

And please spare me any ridiculous justification for this nonsense all in the name of saving money.

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Friday 11.26.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Posts to ponder from the Methoblogosphere:

Taylor Walters Denyer writes on family, food, and collapsing the cake.

Troy Plummer posts on zero tolerance zones.

Dave Camphouse reflects on the book signing one week later.

Will fear keep the local churches in line? Read Jeremy Smith.

Jim Parsons preaches an Advent sermon on hope.

Mark Conforti comments on the Homeless Awareness Lock Out (HALO).

Will Rice posts some thoughts on u/connect.

A reminder from Scott Endress that surrender can be gentle.

Ken Hagler writes on the church you never knew you wanted.

Michael Ledbetter cogitates on keeping the Sabbath.

Tony Mitchell ponders our obsession with time.

United Methodist Student Day and others-- a post from Tim McClendon.

Thursday, November 25, 2010

Have a Blessed Thanksgiving!

Opinion Central Poll 2010.36: Final Results

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Thursday 11.25.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Today's reads from the Methoblogosphere:

Dave Faulkner on Jack Rutter.

Greg Hazelrig Posts his thought for the day on Casting Crowns.

God's Shalom/God's Kingdom-- reflections from Katie Ladd.

Josh Tinely on why I love and hate the Internet.

Your kingdom come... according to Daniel McLain Hixon.

Sky McCracken ponders role reversal.

David Hallam cogitates on disturbing perspectives on faith.

Cathy Turner on the Glad Game.

Discounting-- from Steve Heyduck.

Melissa Cooper writes a letter to a liberal from a former conservative.

Mike Lindstrom is on a thrill ride.

Kathy Randall is thankful. Read her post and you will be too.

Wednesday, November 24, 2010

A Bibliophile's Playground

I am an unashamed bibliophile and if there is a cure for the disease, I will not be undergoing treatment. I simply refuse. Visiting the book stalls of all the different publishers at SBL with their discounted prices is as close to heaven on earth that I experience. Here is a partial list of what I purchased in Atlanta at the recent annual meeting:

-The Society of Biblical Literature was giving out for free their edition of the Greek New Testament. I already have several Greek NTs, but... did I mention it was free? You can download it here.

-I purchased the paperback edition of the Hebrew Old Testament, Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, which means no more carrying around the big hardback Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia, the Hernia Edition.

-Richard Bauckham, The Theology of the Book of Revelation. Yes, Revelation does have a theology.

-Lee C. Barrett, III, Kierkegaard. I love Kierkegaard!

-Donald W. Musser and Joseph L. Price, Tillich. I'm not a big fan of Paul Tillich's theology, but I am always willing to read in order to risk conversion.

-Adam Neder, Participation in Christ: An Entry into Karl Barth's Church Dogmatics. If it's about Barth or he wrote it, I'm interested in it.

-Stanley Porter and Cynthia Westfall (eds.), Empire in the New Testament. This one's brand new and hot off the presses. I'm going to be contributing an essay on Empire and Colossians to an anthology this year.

-Michael Cartwright, Practices, Politics, and Performance: Toward a Communal Hermeneutic for Christian Ethics. Michael and I were students at Duke Divinity School at the same time. I read his original dissertation version of this work. It is a must read for anyone interested in biblical interpretation and Christian Ethics.

-John Polkinghorne (ed.) The Trinity and an Entangled World: Relationality in Physical Science and Theology. I read everything I can get my hands on by Polkinghorne, who is a physicist and an Anglican priest. If he edited this volume, it must be good.

-Peter J. Leithart, Defending Constantine: The Twilight of an Empire and the Dawn of Christendom. I'm not a big fan of what John Howard Yoder called "The Constantinian Shift," but as I said, I am always willing to read to risk conversion.

-Michael Licona, The Resurrection of Jesus: A New Historiographical Approach. I'm really into Jesus' resurrection! When you think about it, it is truly a cool doctrine!

This list is more than sufficient. Now, if you'll excuse me, I have a cup of Earl Grey Tea and a book waiting for me.

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Wednesday 11.24.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Some links from the Methoblogosphere:

Kim Matthews conjures up some magic words.

Richard Hall writes on the election of The Methodist Youth Assembly's new president.

Advent thoughts on hope from Andy Bryan.

Whisperings from Greg Milinovich on the ghost in the wind.

Robert McDowell reflects on the qualities of a good leader.

Dan Dick on the DMC-- the Divided Methodist Church.

Forming thoughts on The Foundation from Andrew Stoddard.

Beth Quick sermonizes on beginning and ending.

John Meunier wants to know how you would handle this hypothetical conversation.

Mark Winter is the Breckenridge Rider.

Wouldn't you like to be a charismatic Christian too? Read Randy Olds.

Dave Nichols cogitates on upholding the church with our gifts.

Tuesday, November 23, 2010

Graduate Level Cheating on Demand

From The Chronicle of Higher Education (HT: Scot McKnight):

You've never heard of me, but there's a good chance that you've read some of my work. I'm a hired gun, a doctor of everything, an academic mercenary. My customers are your students. I promise you that. Somebody in your classroom uses a service that you can't detect, that you can't defend against, that you may not even know exists.

I work at an online company that generates tens of thousands of dollars a month by creating original essays based on specific instructions provided by cheating students. I've worked there full time since 2004. On any day of the academic year, I am working on upward of 20 assignments.

In the midst of this great recession, business is booming. At busy times, during midterms and finals, my company's staff of roughly 50 writers is not large enough to satisfy the demands of students who will pay for our work and claim it as their own.

For those of you who have ever mentored a student through the writing of a dissertation, served on a thesis-review committee, or guided a graduate student through a formal research process, I have a question: Do you ever wonder how a student who struggles to formulate complete sentences in conversation manages to produce marginally competent research? How does that student get by you?

I live well on the desperation, misery, and incompetence that your educational system has created. Granted, as a writer, I could earn more; certainly there are ways to earn less. But I never struggle to find work. And as my peers trudge through thankless office jobs that seem more intolerable with every passing month of our sustained recession, I am on pace for my best year yet. I will make roughly $66,000 this year. Not a king's ransom, but higher than what many actual educators are paid.

Of course, I know you are aware that cheating occurs. But you have no idea how deeply this kind of cheating penetrates the academic system, much less how to stop it. Last summer The New York Times reported that 61 percent of undergraduates have admitted to some form of cheating on assignments and exams. Yet there is little discussion about custom papers and how they differ from more-detectable forms of plagiarism, or about why students cheat in the first place.

It is my hope that this essay will initiate such a conversation. As for me, I'm planning to retire. I'm tired of helping you make your students look competent.

I have completed countless online courses. Students provide me with passwords and user names so I can access key documents and online exams. In some instances, I have even contributed to weekly online discussions with other students in the class.

I do a lot of work for seminary students. I like seminary students. They seem so blissfully unaware of the inherent contradiction in paying somebody to help them cheat in courses that are largely about walking in the light of God and providing an ethical model for others to follow. I have been commissioned to write many a passionate condemnation of America's moral decay as exemplified by abortion, gay marriage, or the teaching of evolution. All in all, we may presume that clerical authorities see these as a greater threat than the plagiarism committed by the future frocked.

I, who have no name, no opinions, and no style, have written so many papers at this point, including legal briefs, military-strategy assessments, poems, lab reports, and, yes, even papers on academic integrity, that it's hard to determine which course of study is most infested with cheating. But I'd say education is the worst. I've written papers for students in elementary-education programs, special-education majors, and ESL-training courses. I've written lesson plans for aspiring high-school teachers, and I've synthesized reports from notes that customers have taken during classroom observations. I've written essays for those studying to become school administrators, and I've completed theses for those on course to become principals. In the enormous conspiracy that is student cheating, the frontline intelligence community is infiltrated by double agents. (Future educators of America, I know who you are.)
___
You can read "The Shadow Scholar" in its entirety here.

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Tuesday 11.23.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Today's reads from the Methoblogosphere:

Bishop William Willimon on accentuating the positive.

During this holiday season Nancy Johnson reminds us that we have enough.

Matt Kelley ponders thirty years later.

The class meeting as the method of Methodism-- a post from Steve Manskar.

Brian Russell writes on Exodus and mission.

Kathy James offers more thoughts on forgiveness.

Guy Kent narrates on working part-time.

"Living in an 'it is what it is' world"-- a sermon from Ken Carter.

What do you do when God takes over? Read Sally Coleman.

Henry Neufeld comments on the Gospel Lection for Christ the King Sunday.

Becca Clark issues a call to #OurExamine.

Richard Heyduck reports on the Global Faith Forum.

Monday, November 22, 2010

Muddling Through a "Somehow Beside the Point" Situation

I have been attending the Society of Biblical Literature Annual Meeting which is being held this year in Atlanta. I look forward to attending every year, even though the American Academy of Religion had a Forrest Gump "stupid is as stupid does" moment a few years ago and broke away from the joint conference to do their own thing. (Fortunately, the two societies will be together next year in San Francisco.) It's a great time to see old friends again and network and discuss the latest publishing possibilities and buy lots of books at discounted prices... and I even manage to attend a session here and there to hear a paper or two.

Having said that, I spend a fair chunk of time each year at SBL wondering and asking myself, "What's the point?" I love Christian scholarship and I believe that the primary task of such scholarship is to serve the church. And while there is such scholarship here, I will be bold enough to say that not all of it is-- indeed, I suspect that more than a small percentage of the scholarship at SBL is of little to no help in serving the church as it fulfills the mission Christ gave to it; and I suspect that more than a small percentage of scholars here could care less about the ecclesiological implications of their scholarly pursuits.
.
Please hear me! There are folks who do care about their scholarship as it relates to the church and they are here in Atlanta swarming the area. My wonderful colleagues at Ashland Theological Seminary are among them. But I dare say that the ecclesiological dimensions of the SBL enterprise are woefully lacking, and not only are they woefully lacking, there appears to be at times little interest in doing theology while standing in the wise and watchful gaze of the church.

If what I do as a scholar does not assist in the church's fulfillment of the Great Commission our Lord and Savior gave it on behalf of the world, then my scholarly pursuits are a waste of time, and nothing I write on and reflect over should be taken seriously (not that anyone does, anyway). Christian scholarship should not be an exercise unto itself. As Karl Barth so astutely noted many years ago-- the only good reason for the theologian to exist is to give the preacher something to say on Sunday morning. Before his Ascension, Jesus said to his disciples, "Go into the world and make disciples of all nations." If my study and research and writing do not assist in the Great Commission endeavor, then all my work and toil and labor is a waste of time, and Jesus will not be able to say to me upon my entrance to the Kingdom, "Well done, good and faithful servant!" And those are words I want to hear someday above every other affirmation.

So, as I muddle my way each year through the SBL conundrum, I pledge to God each year that my scholarly endeavors will not be pursued for the affirmation of my earthly peers, but for Jesus Christ who makes it possible for me to be here in Atlanta among these important (though sometimes beside the point) deliberations.
___
Here's a wonderful post on Day 1 at SBL from friend and fellow Durhamite, Ken Schenck.

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Monday 11.22.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Monday's musings from the Methoblogosphere:

Pat LaPorte has an urgent prayer request.

Andrew Thompson is involved in an exciting new project. Congratulations, Andrew!

Dale Tedder's Aunt Lucy was an example of Kingdom discipleship.

Reflections on the reign of Christ and Colossians from Sue Whitt.

Shane Raynor cogitates on entering the spiritual dimension.

Jay Voorhees writes on setting the stage in the drive for discipleship.

How Do you read the Bible? Angela Shier-Jones asks the question.

Dave Warnock posts on the resurgence of awesome women of the Reformation.

John Carney reflects on the first last word.

What is the "ah-ha" moment? Betty Newman explains.

Did you know that having good friends and neighbours boosts your chances of survival? So explains Lorna Koskela.

Joseph Yoo ponders volunteering vs. serving.

Sunday, November 21, 2010

Christ the King and Partisan Politics

Today is Christ the King Sunday. It is the last Sunday of the liturgical year, which will begin anew next Sunday with the season of Advent. When the New Testament proclaims that Jesus is Lord, it is not simply an affirmation that Jesus reigns in our individual hearts and lives; it is a radical political claim meant to put the nations of the world and their leaders on notice. In the Roman Empire, it was common to swear allegiance to the Emperor with the shout, "Caesar is Lord." When the Christians substituted Jesus for Caesar, they were making a significant claim about the nature of Christ's lordship, and the ultimate insignificance of Caesar as one who determines the destiny of human history.
.
To be sure, the first Christians took the rule of the Emperor quite seriously, but they also knew that since God was now beginning to set the world to rights in the lordship of Jesus Christ, Caesar was simply on borrowed time. So while it is possible for believers to be involved in the politics that is the world, such polity is not at the center of human history; rather it is the politics of the Kingdom displayed in the church. As I have said many times, when most Christians hear the word "politics" they think "nation-state." The word I wish they would centrally associate with "politics" is "church." The politics of the nations stand at the margins because Jesus is Lord, not any Caesar, king, president or prime minister. Such an understanding gave the first Christians a view of worldly politics that was quite restrained in reference to what it could accomplish and how little a role it would play in bringing history to God’s desired fulfillment.
.
My concern with Christians who are partisan on both sides of the political aisle is that they often unwittingly give Caesar the center stage of human history that should only be reserved for Christ. I know partisan Republican Christians who are excited beyond measure over the recent mid-term elections as if the Kingdom of God once again has a chance of being restored in America after the political heresy of the last two years. I know partisan Democratic Christians who, since November 2, are almost inconsolably depressed as if the Gates of Hell are now prevailing against their Kingdom of Social Justice. But it is the Psalmist who states, "Do not put your trust in princes, in mortals who cannot save. When their spirit departs, they return to the ground; on that very day their plans come to nothing" (146:3-4). When Christ is truly confessed as King, our trust in the leaders of the world, including those who hold our political views, will always be severely qualified. The problem is not only a partisanship of political conviction, it is a partisanship of confidence in the politics of the world.
.
Perhaps the major problem with partisan Christians on both sides is that they suffer from the malady of an anemic political ecclesiology brought on by Christendom, which is nurtured and fed by the belief that the church's most significant task is to be the prop for the state instead of providing the alternative to it. It is the acceptance of the false notion that the nation is where the political action is instead of in the church, which is the only body that has the resources capable of sustaining the kind of polity that bears witness to the lordship of Jesus Christ. It is not the church that stands on the political margins; how can that be the case since it is God and not the nations who rules the world?
.
Christ is King. Jesus is Lord. Words to remember before we place too much trust in the mortal princes of the world on this Christ the King Sunday.

Thursday, November 18, 2010

It's that SBL Time of the Year

I'm off to Atlanta, Georgia to attend the Society of Biblical Literature Annual Meeting. I'll be doing some blogging from there.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

Whatever Happened to the Thanksgiving Season?

When I was a boy, there were two clear and demarcated holiday seasons: Thanksgiving and Christmas. After Halloween, it was the season to prepare for the Thanksgiving holiday. The Christmas season did not begin until the day after Thanksgiving. No one decorated for Christmas until after Turkey Day, and even though some stores had Christmas decorations on display prior, the real celebration did not begin until the end of November.

Those days appear to be long gone. After Halloween (which is now celebrated with an emphasis I never witnessed as a boy) we immediately enter the Christmas season in high gear. Stores have their decorations displayed by the end of October, some even before; and people are decorating their houses beginning in November. And while we still have a recognized Thanksgiving holiday in the U.S., it now appears as nothing more than a blip on the radar screen of the holiday season, and every year some inquire as to what has happened.

But we all know what has happened-- the celebration of Christmas, like everything else in American culture, has become a commodity. Madison Avenue could never figure out how to make serious money off of Thanksgiving, so the task then was to lengthen the Christmas season. Given the consumer mentality of the Christmas season and the enticing lure of lights, decorations, and Christmas music, it was not too difficult to put Americans in Christmas mode earlier and earlier. If this keeps up we will literally be having Christmas in July.

I am simply making observations here. I am not proposing some kind of remedy to the loss of the Thanksgiving season because the celebration of Christmas has become a rather strange anomaly for me as my thinking has changed over the years. Yes, I do celebrate Christmas with family and friends, but I have truly come to believe that it is quite odd to celebrate God's self-emptying in Jesus Christ with unbridled greed and materialism, while we push and shove people in the stores the day after Thanksgiving to get the latest technological gadgets that the stores purposely stock in limited numbers. And for those of you who are planning to start the shopping spree early in the morning on November 26 this year, just know that the retail establishment is greedily taking advantage of your greed.

It would be preferable to deck the halls only after Thanksgiving, but since it seems we will not be returning to a more rational and disciplined situation any time soon, at least some of us can beat the drum of reminder of how far the actual celebration of the birth of Christ has strayed from what it truly means for "Immanuel"-- "God With Us,"-- to have taken the form of flesh on our behalf.

Christmas is not your birthday. It is not mine. But judging from the way we observe the holiday each year, one would think otherwise.

Monday, November 15, 2010

John Wesley on Predestination

There was much in the theology of John Calvin that Wesley appreciated and agreed with. He wrote that on justification he and Calvin were but a "hair's breadth" away on the doctrine. Wesley also liked much of Calvin's doctrine of the Holy Spirit (He thought Luther's account of the Spirit was "stunted").

But when it came to the Calvinist understanding of predestination, Wesley pounded the pulpit expressing himself in no uncertain terms. Even though he published an essay entitled, "Predestination Calmly Considered," there was nothing gentle about Wesley's response. In his sermon "Free Grace," Wesley referred to the Calvinist view that God has assigned some to hell as portraying "God as worse than the devil." Like Calvin, Wesley believed that God is the one who takes the initiative to offer salvation. Without grace salvation is impossible. But, unlike Calvin, the offer is made to all, and all persons, through God's prevenient grace, have the opportunity to respond. Divine grace is necessary for saving faith, but such grace can be resisted by the individual.
.
Father John's problems with Calvin's "double-predestination" can be summarized in a three-fold manner: First, it is a rejection of free will. Thus, our seeming choices are not choices at all; it is simply smoke and mirrors.

Second, it raises serious questions about the justice of God, who holds persons accountable for something they cannot choose in the first place. It is tantamount to a parent insisting her child spill his juice on the carpet and then punishing him for it.


Third, it undermines the motivation for Christian discipleship and mission. Why go into the world and preach the gospel if it has already been determined who is saved and who is condemned? The Calvinist response that we should preach the gospel because Christ commands it, still does not deal with the truth that those chosen for life will accept it, whether we preach or not, and those assigned to perdition will reject the message, whether we proclaim it or not; the decrees of God, after all, will not be falsified.


Wesley quotes 2 Peter 3:9: "The Lord is not willing that any should perish, but that all should come to repentance." For Wesley, the Calvinist doctrine of predestination is contrary to the testimony of Scripture that God offers the invitation to all and that all are able to accept it.

Saturday, November 13, 2010

What It Means for God's Name to Be Holy

God's name is made holy, not just in our words, but in our very lives. It is for this reason, that even though our relationship with God might be intimate in nature, it isn't one of equals, lest we seek to take advantage of God's name and profane that name in the way we live.

With the prophet, we may cry out to God, seeking God's mercy and forgiveness, so that we might live anew this petition that God's name might be hallowed in our lives. And if God's name is made holy, then with the prophet we may experience great joy and find our calling in life. With this as our starting point, we can continue the journey through this prayer, contemplating its meaning for our lives.

---

You can read more reflections on the prayer Jesus taught his disciples in Bob Cornwall's new book, Ultimate Allegiance: The Subversive Nature of The Lord's Prayer.

Thursday, November 11, 2010

Caption Contest 2010.12... And the Winner Is...

Jimmy O.: San-ta got run o-ver by an air-plane... com-ing back from our house Christ-mas Eve. You may say there's no such thing as San-ta... but trust me when I tell you he's been creamed.

Wednesday, November 10, 2010

Thirty-Five Years Ago Today...

...the Edmund Fitzgerald sank in a storm on Lake Superior as the freighter was bound for Cleveland, Ohio. I was thirteen years old and remember well the news that day.

Opinion Central Poll 2010.35: Final Results

Tuesday, November 09, 2010

Houston, We Have a Problem!

Well, not really... but with my schedule for the next two weeks, blogging will be at the bottom of my list of things to do. I thought I could do it, but after reviewing my schedule I see that my regular blogging pace has to be revised for approximately the next fortnight (for my fellow Americans who do not know what a fortnight is, click here). I will publish a few posts, to be sure, but I will not be posting the Methodist Blogs Daily Links nor the Saturday Methodist Blogs Weekly Roundup for the next two weeks.

After that my blogging should resume in normal fashion.

Monday, November 08, 2010

Caption Contest 2010.12

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Monday 11.8.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Monday's posts from the Methoblogosphere:

Andy Bryan offers continued thoughts on discipleship continued.

Jay Voorhees has some questions on United Methodist parsonages.

Dave Faulkner comments on the controversial sermon that started, Jesus had HIV."

Tomato Pie and Politics-- a post from Nancy Johnson.

Rick Weber writes on trip-wire vets.

Shane Raynor ponders evangelizing people of other faiths.

Sally Coleman reflects on pastoral care in a digital age.

It's not fair-- according to Angela Shier-Jones.

Greg Hazelrig posts his thought for the day on Galatians 6:4.

Mark Winter reports that the circuit rider has visted the children.

Dan Dick cogitates on anti-socialism.

Part one of two on Hades in the Gospels from Randy Olds.

Sunday, November 07, 2010

On This All Saints' Sunday

A Prayer for All Saints' Sunday

Almighty God, who has knit together your elect in one communion and fellowship in the mystical body of Your Son, Christ our Lord: Give us grace so to follow Your blessed saints in all virtuous and godly living, that we may come to those ineffable joys that you have prepared for those who unfeignedly love you; through the same Jesus Christ our Lord, who with you and the Holy Spirit lives and reigns, one God, in glory everlasting. Amen.

The Book of Common Prayer

Saturday, November 06, 2010

Don't Forget...

...to set your clocks back one hour tonight.

Where I Am on the Political Spectrum

I am always a little leery of taking these kinds of quizzes because some of the questions are not sufficiently nuanced for me, so I am not sure how to answer. I took this same quiz a couple of years ago, but I do not remember where I landed on the grid. Moreover, I find the whole left/right, conservative/liberal political dichotomy assumes certain political and philosophical underpinnings that are, in my view, incompatible with Jesus' Kingdom ethic. But in any case, it was an interesting quiz to take if for no other reason than to have someone else inform me of what they think I believe.

My Political Views
I am a center-right social moderate
Right: 2.05, Libertarian: 0.31

Political Spectrum Quiz


My Foreign Policy Views
Score: -3.22

Political Spectrum Quiz


My Culture War Stance
Score: 0.28

Political Spectrum Quiz

---

The Methodist Blogs Weekly Roundup 2010.29.240

Any Methoblogger who would like a link in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

If you discover that a link is not correct, please email me at the above address.

*Thanks to everyone for their email submissions.*

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Monday 11.1.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Tuesday 11.2.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Wednesday 11.3.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Thursday 11.4.10

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Friday 11.5.10

This week's Best of the Methoblogosphere!

Bishop Robert Schnase: "The Vicious Habit"

Dan Dick: "A.D.D.-U.M.C."

Friday, November 05, 2010

Truth Is Stranger than Fiction 2010.21: Don't Drink and Drive Dressed as a Breathalyzer

Halloween Reveler Dressed As Breathalyzer Busted For Drunk Driving

In the most amusing meta moment from the Halloween police blotter, a Nebraska man dressed as a portable Breathalyzer machine was arrested for drunk driving.

Matthew Nieveen, 19, was busted early Monday for DUI and being a minor in possession of alcohol. Nieveen was collared after a Lincoln cop pulled over his Ford F-150 after the teenager was spotted driving erratically. Though cops identified Nieveen, they decided to black out his face in a photo snapped post-arrest.

Nieveen’s blood alcohol level was more than twice the state’s .08 limit (though he wasn’t supposed to be drinking in the first place). A search of his truck turned up a bottle of vodka and beer.

Last Halloween, an Ohio college student wearing a similar Breathalyzer costume was busted for drunk driving and underage drinking.
---
Source: The Smoking Gun

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Friday 11.5.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Posts to ponder from the Methoblogosphere:

"Nothing Separates Us From God and Each Other, Not Even Death"-- a sermon by Katie Ladd.

Jeremy Smith wonders of discipleship could be an RPG.

Jim Parsons preaches on the "God of the Living."

Dave Warnock attended the Blessings Workshop.

It's another food holiday for Nancy Johnson.

Josh Tinley reflects on voting.

John Carney gives a podcast update.

William T. Chaney comments on the purpose of the 30 Day Challenge and invites all to join him.

Is your Elohim Yahweh? Betty Newman wants to know.

Andrew Stoddard ponders the stuff of earth or heaven.

Will European style protests happen in the U.S. Daniel McLain Hixon cogitates on the question.

Sky McCracken writes on restoring, renewing, and trying something new.

Thursday, November 04, 2010

Economics in America, the 2010 Election, and the Church's Active Witness

Scot McKnight has written a helpful post on his blog entitled, "American Economics for Europeans." It's worth a read as well as the subsequent comments thread.

My major interest in mentioning Scot's post, however, is to highlight something Scot writes in the comments thread which encapsulates nicely what I refer to as the church's central political task as one of witness. I quote his comments in full and my italics highlight what I believe are the key observations. Words in bold get to the heart of the matter in reference to the politics of witness. (By the way, I do not assume that Scot would agree with everything in the way I frame the discussion, but we do have similar points of view on this subject.)

The sensibility of caring for others, charity etc, is written into the American fabric more through volunteerism than through taxation, though since mid20th Century and on it has become increasingly seen as the government's job. But the implication of assigning that task to the government requires more taxes, and that grates the nerves for many (if not most). Hence, we have expectations but don't want to do what it takes. I'm not sure there’s another way of saying it better.

How widespread? It's our ethos and our mode of being and it's written into the pages of our history. But, one can't speak for this being universal in the USA since many have needed governmental assistance and, frankly, our lack of checks and balances have at times created an almost dependence on the government for some.

I get what you mean by affluent vs. poor here, but I think it is more middle class and affluent than anything else. The Tea Party, which is making some of Thomas Paine's themes more prominent than they have been in years, is not really an affluent society group but a working class, middle class group.

The "freedom" point: well, it can be looked at in either good or bad directions. Yes, Americans want to choose to whom they give their money rather than to have the Feds tell us to give our money. So, the resistance to taxation is an expression of freedom not to … and there are many today, though I doubt a majority, who want to see charitable actions to be given back to the person and to the local community and removed from the purview and control of the Feds.

On intersection with the gospel, now you're meddling! It is a mistake for Christians to trust in the government to care for others; Christians ought to have the compassion to care enough for others that they voluntarily choose to help others. So, the question for the Christian is not "if" but "how" and "how is this done best?"

I believe followers of Jesus ought to be leaders in these areas. Local churches ought to be beachheads of compassion and justice for that local community. Christians ought not to be the ones who think poverty means, tout simple, laziness. Christians ought to be sensitive to systemic hermeneutics, but instead of being blamers they ought to be restorers.

But I'm not naive. There aren't enough Christians like this to solve the problems or meet the needs, so Christians ought to be able to make public appeals to Americans to consider the needs of others. That means I would support a mixture of faith-based compassion [and I'm happy to tell you that our church, Willow Creek, is a leader in these matters] and government-based assistance. But government-based assistance needs to be managed better and it needs to be remedial and temporary. We have a tendency to think that giving money solves problems.

The single-most important element in solving poverty in the USA is the creation of jobs, but that has to occur alongside immediate and urgent help of those in need. I don't believe we are doing enough to create jobs. Obama has had only two years but his focus on health care has eclipsed his concern with job creation too much. That is why the vote of Nov 2 happened as it did.

Anyone wanting to comment is welcome to do so.

The Methodist Blogs Daily Links-- Thursday 11.4.10

Any Methoblogger who would like a link posted in the MBDL, email it to mbdailylinks(at)yahoo(dot)com. Your link will be posted within two weekdays. No blog will be listed more than once a week.

Today's reads from the Methoblogosphere:

Christopher Gudger-Raines reflects on high-heeled footprints in the sand.

After we die, does God need us in heaven? Kim Matthews has some thoughts on the matter.

Matt Kelley posts on a tragic loss.

Richard Hall writes on Christians in Iraq.

Rick Weber comments on the church growth hucksters.

Perfect freedom according to Steve Manskar.

Kathy Randall ponders a prompt of six.

Lorna Koskela reminds us that culture does good.

Drew Mack informs us that Duke and Notre Dame are #1.

Bumber sticker theology-- reflections from Steve Heyduck.

Tim Good states, "Ask and you shall receive?"

Do you have a place where it all comes together? Read Larry Oksten.

Wednesday, November 03, 2010

Did the Ancient Israelites Drink Beer?

That's what Michael Homan argues in the September/October issue of Biblical Archaeology Review. If this is so how come we don't find beer mentioned in the Old Testament and why hasn't this been a topic of any interest in biblical scholarship?

Homan cites three reasons for the lack of knowledge and interest in Hebrew beer brewers: 1) the Hebrew word shekhar (שכר) has been misunderstood, 2) there is a general scholarly "snobbery" concerning beer drinking as opposed to the consumption of wine, and 3) the difficulty in identifying the remains of tools and items in the production of beer.

Now for a little more detail on Homan's three reasons:

1) Most English translations of the Old Testament render shekhar as "strong drink" or "liquor," and other terminology that would lead one to believe that the word does not refer to beer. But in the Hebrew Bible the word appears twenty times in parallel with "wine" (e.g. wine and beer). In other ancient Near Eastern literature the terms for wine and beer are often used in tandem. Moreover, the Hebrew word shekhar is derived from the Akkadian word šikaru which refers to "barley beer."

2) Ancient historians know that beer was a staple drink throughout the Ancient Near East. Why would the Israelites be an exception? We know that grain was grown widely throughout this part of the ancient world because it was easy to grow. Unlike grain, grapes cannot be grown just anywhere. Beer was used as wages and ancient physicians recommended a beer enema for such ailments as constipation. Hammurabi's Law Code legislates the price and the alcoholic content of beer.

One of the reasons scholars have not embraced beer drinking Israelites is that alcoholic beverages were often mixed. The ancient folk sometimes sweetened their beer with figs or honey. They also added spices. Interestingly enough it has been the advent of modern microbreweries with all the different kinds of flavored and spiced beers that have helped to clear up the ambiguity in reference to ancient beers.

A second reason is that the word shekhar also was the term used to refer to intoxication. This was also true of the word for "beer" in the Akkadian, Aramaic, Ugaritic, and Arabic languages.

Combine the connection of shekhar to the state of inebriation with the vision of the guy with the dirty t-shirt sitting in front of the TV drinking a bottle of cheap swill, scholars have not sufficiently considered the important place of beer in Israelite society. There has been an unspoken assumption that beer drinking is uncivilized.

3) It is been difficult to find archaeological evidence for ancient beer making in Israel because much of the same equipment was also used to make bread. This would be understandable, says Homan, since in the ancient world beer and bread were closely connected. In addition, it is more difficult to find chemical traces of ancient beer in jars and other pottery because, unlike wine, ancient beer did not keep long and was brewed for immediate consumption. Beer drinking was also a community activity. One method of consumption was for several people to drink it from a large communal pot through straws.

Homan ends the article with Ecclesiastes 11:1-2:

Throw your bread upon the face of the water, because in many days you will acquire it. Give a serving to seven and also eight, because you do not know what evil will be upon the land.

Homan thinks these two verses are a reference to the cakes of bread used in the brewing of ancient beer. Thus the sage of Ecclesiastes is advising his hearers to make beer and drink it with friends because no one knows when future calamity is coming.

This Methodist preacher is trying to figure out how to preach that to his congregation!
---
For those who wish to read the full article from BAR, the link is here.